Federal judge dismisses Kash Patel’s defamation suit against Frank Figliuzzi
The Facts
- A federal judge in Texas dismissed Kash Patel’s defamation lawsuit against Frank Figliuzzi.
- The lawsuit stemmed from Figliuzzi’s televised comment that Patel had been visible at nightclubs more than on the seventh floor of FBI headquarters.
- Judge George Hanks Jr. ruled that Figliuzzi’s statement was “rhetorical hyperbole” and could not constitute defamation.
- The judge said a reasonable person would not have understood Figliuzzi’s remark literally as a factual claim about Patel’s whereabouts.
- The court concluded that Patel failed to state a viable defamation claim against Figliuzzi.
- Figliuzzi is a former FBI official who has worked as an MSNBC or NBC News contributor/analyst.
- The comment at issue was made on 'Morning Joe,' which sources note now airs on MS NOW.
Analytical frames for this storyTap to explore
Context
Why did the judge dismiss the case?
Judge George Hanks Jr. said Figliuzzi’s nightclub remark was “rhetorical hyperbole,” meaning it was not reasonably understood as a literal statement of fact and therefore could not support a defamation claim Hill,Anadolu Ajansı,TheWrap.
View all 36 sources
Wire services (1)
Independent coverage (35)
Black America WebJudge Tosses Suit Against Former FBI Agent Who Suggested Kas...
News OneKash Patel Lawuit Against Former FBI Agent Dismissed
Crooks and LiarsKash Patel Loses Defamation Suit About His Nightclubbing
The Free Press - TampaNightclub Comments Ruled "Hyperbole" As FBI Director's Defam...
International Business Times UKKash Patel Dealt Major Court Blow in Defamation Lawsuit as J...
Above the LawKash Patel's $250 Million Lawsuit Was Going Fine Until He St...
law360.comKash Patel's Suit Over Pundit's 'Nightclubs' Quip Gets Axed ...
AolJudge tosses Kash Patel's defamation suit against former MSN...
Resist the MainstreamPatel Suffers Brutal Blow
OpEdNewsKash Patel Loses Defamation Suit About His Nightclubbing
BeritajaJudge Tosses Kash Patel's Defamation Suit Against Former Msn...
NBC NewsJudge tosses Kash Patel's defamation suit against former MSN...
NewserJudge Tosses Kash Patel's Other Defamation Lawsuit
The HillJudge dismisses Patel defamation lawsuit over 'nightclubs' c...
UPIJudge dismisses FBI Director Kash Patel's defamation lawsuit...
MS NOWPatel loses defamation case against ex-MSNBC analyst that he...
New York PostJudge dismisses Kash Patel's MSNBC lawsuit over columnist's ...
We Got This CoveredWas the FBI Director really at nightclubs 'more than work?' ...
TMZKash Patel's Defamation Lawsuit Against Former FBI Official ...
Law & CrimeKash Patel already loses defamation case over how he spends ...
Washington ExaminerJudge dismisses Kash Patel's defamation lawsuit against form...
International Business Times UKA Court Just Ruled That Calling Kash Patel a 'Nightclub Regu...
100 Percent Fed UpFederal Court Judge Rules On Kash Patel's Defamation Lawsuit...
The IndependentKash Patel's 'nightclubs' lawsuit against news analyst is th...
NewsweekAnother Kash Patel defamation lawsuit was just dismissed
MandatoryFBI Director Kash Patel Faces Major Rejection From Judge Ove...
Democratic UndergroundJudge dismisses Kash Patel's defamation lawsuit over claim h...
HuffPostJudge Tosses Kash Patel's Lawsuit Over TV Analyst's 'Nightcl...
Anadolu AjansıUS judge dismisses FBI director's defamation lawsuit against...
The Daily BeastJudge Tosses Out Keystone Kash's Defamation Lawsuit
Democratic UndergroundJudge rules FBI pundit Frank Figliuzzi's contested criticism...
DeadlineJudge Tosses Kash Patel's Defamation Lawsuit Against Frank F...
DNyuzKash Patel's lawsuit against legal commentator thrown out
Raw StoryKash Patel's lawsuit against legal commentator thrown out
ReasonFBI Director Kash Patel Loses Defamation Lawsuit Over Mornin...
About these frames
The Advocate: Liberty, speech, privacy, autonomy, rights, consent, choice. What freedoms are at stake.
The Architect: Stability, law, enforcement, institutional design, separation of powers, regulatory process, rule of law. How are order and governance maintained?
The Watchdog: Wrongdoing, responsibility, corruption, transparency. Who knew what, when, and what they did about it.
See this differently than someone you know would? Two ways to keep it going.
The dial works on any URL — paste an article you read elsewhere this week.