Seven states sue Trump administration over cancellation of New York offshore wind lease
The Facts
- Seven states led by New York filed a lawsuit on June 2 challenging the Trump administration's cancellation of a major offshore wind lease off the coast of New York.
- The states joining New York are Connecticut, Maine, Massachusetts, New Jersey, Rhode Island and Vermont.
- The lawsuit challenges a March agreement under which the federal government canceled TotalEnergies-related offshore wind leases tied to projects off New York and North Carolina.
- Multiple reports say the agreement provided TotalEnergies a reimbursement of roughly $795 million to nearly $1 billion in connection with ending the offshore wind projects.
- According to the lawsuit, the agreement also required or secured a commitment from TotalEnergies not to pursue new offshore wind projects in the United States and to direct investment toward fossil fuel projects.
- The states argue the cancellation of the New York lease would harm their economies, electric grids or energy supply planning, and climate goals.
- The legal challenge was filed in federal court in Washington, D.C., and seeks to have the agreement set aside and the lease cancellation vacated.
- One unresolved issue is whether the court will agree with the states' claim that the Interior Department lacked legal authority or failed to follow required procedures when canceling the lease.
How left and right are reading this
- Both agree
- The disputed March deal did more than cancel one offshore wind lease: it reportedly paired the cancellation with a massive reimbursement and commitments shaping future energy investment, making the court fight turn on whether the government lawfully used that power.
- They split on
- Less a disagreement than a question of emphasis: the concrete harms the states say the cancellation poses to economies, grid planning, energy supply, and climate goals, versus the narrower institutional question of whether Interior had authority and followed required procedures.
Analytical frames for this storyTap to explore
Context
What exactly are the states challenging?
They are challenging a March federal agreement that canceled an offshore wind lease off New York, ended related projects off New York and North Carolina, and provided TotalEnergies with a large reimbursement tied to abandoning the developments Guardian,Reuters,Philadelphia Inquir….
Why do the states say the case matters to them?
The states say losing the New York offshore wind project would hurt their economies, reduce expected electric power supply, affect grid planning, and undermine their climate goals Yahoo! Finance,U.S. News & World R…,CNN International.
What are the states asking the court to do?
They want the court to strike down the agreement and vacate the lease cancellation, arguing the federal government did not lawfully cancel the lease or follow required procedures CNN International,Axios,theepochtimes.com.
View all 75 sources
Wire services (4)
Independent coverage (50)
Mother JonesSix states are suing the Trump administration over its deal ...
Daily DispatchUS states sue Trump administration over deal to scrap offsho...
No2NuclearPowerUS - Offshore Wind
YahooNew York leads coalition challenging $1bn wind lease settlem...
elEconomista.esGuerra judicial por el pacto de Trump con TotalEnergies: una...
cnbctv18.comUS states sue Trump administration over deal to scrap offsho...
RivieraNew York-led lawsuit challenges Trump's offshore wind buyout...
98.9 WCLZMaine Joins Lawsuit Against Trump Administration Over End of...
NTDNY and 6 States Sue Federal Government Over Canceled Wind Pr...
CleanTechnicaTotalEnergies On Hot Seat Over Offshore Wind Lease Deal
www.theepochtimes.comNY and 6 States Sue Federal Government Over Canceled Wind Pr...
The News InternationalTrump administration faces lawsuit over $1 billion offshore ...
La Voz de MichoacánDemandarán a gobierno de Trump por desviar dinero de energía...
La NacionHochul contra Trump: Nueva York demanda al gobierno federal ...
CleanTechnicaSierra Club Applauds Northeast States for Challenging Trump ...
governorswindenergycoalition.orgBlue States Sue Trump Administration Over Offshore Wind Deal...
WMTWMaine joins lawsuit over Trump administration's deal to end ...
ABC News7 states sue Trump administration over nearly $1 billion dea...
PBS.orgNew York, 6 other states sues over the Trump administration'...
Kennebec Journal and Morning SentinelMaine, 6 other states sue Trump over deal to end offshore wi...
ElectrekNew York sues over Interior Dept.'s $1B bribe to an oil comp...
Yahoo!Siete fiscalías demandan al Gobierno Trump por desviar inver...
YahooContrasting Trump's Campaign Against Wind Energy With Promot...
POWER MagazineContrasting Trump's Campaign Against Wind Energy With Promot...
NewsdayNew York leads lawsuit against Trump administration's energy...
GizmodoSeven States Sue Trump for Cancelling New York Offshore Wind...
Westfair CommunicationsNY and CT AGs in lawsuit to reverse Trump's killing offshore...
The Philadelphia InquirerBlue states sue Trump administration over offshore wind deal
Bennington BannerNew York sues over the Trump administration's deal to end an...
nystateofpolitics.comN.Y. sues over the Trump administration's deal to end an off...
The CT MirrorCT joins NY suit over Trump deal to end TotalEnergies wind p...
Common DreamsState AGs Sue Over Trump 'Trying to Kill Clean Energy Projec...
The IndependentSeven states sue Trump administration over offshore wind pro...
Maritime ExecutiveSix-State Coalition Sues to Block Trump's Buyout of Offshore...
GothamistNY AG sues over Trump deal paying French firm to cancel offs...
Insurance JournalNortheast States Sue Trump Administration Over Offshore Wind...
My NBC5New York, Vermont sue over the Trump administration's deal t...
Raw StoryTrump foe leads blue state charge against 'sham deal' cut wi...
CNN InternationalThe Trump admin paid a French company $1 billion to not buil...
CNNThe Trump admin paid a French company $1 billion to not buil...
NewsChannel 3-12The Trump admin paid a French company $1 billion to not buil...
HotAirNo Good Deed: Blue State AGs Suing Over Scuttled Offshore Wi...
CT News JunkieCT Joins Six Northeastern States In Lawsuit Against Trump Ad...
Houston ChronicleNueva York presenta demanda por acuerdo del gobierno de Trum...
Rome SentinelLawsuit alleges Trump used 'illegal' deal to scuttle offshor...
Curated - BLOX Digital Content ExchangeLawsuit alleges Trump used 'illegal' deal to scuttle offshor...
The HillBlue states sue to block Trump's deal to cancel wind lease i...
Washington ExaminerBlue states sue Trump admin over offshore wind lease cancell...
NewsMaxN.Y. Sues Over Trump Deal to End Wind Project
PJ MediaNew York Sues to Save a Costly Wind Dream
About these frames
The Architect: Stability, law, enforcement, institutional design, separation of powers, regulatory process, rule of law. How are order and governance maintained?
The Analyst: Costs, jobs, inflation, growth, incentives, markets, tradeoffs. Follow the money.
The Watchdog: Wrongdoing, responsibility, corruption, transparency. Who knew what, when, and what they did about it.
The First Responder: Who gets hurt or helped. Quality of life, vulnerable groups, public health, human cost and benefit.
See this differently than someone you know would? Two ways to keep it going.
The dial works on any URL — paste an article you read elsewhere this week.